Chicago Public Colleges cannot afford to bail out Metropolis Corridor
This month marks one more turning level within the checkered monetary historical past of Chicago Public Colleges. With a projected $734 million deficit, as estimated by the interim CEO, the Board of Training should cross a finances by the tip of August. The selections made within the coming days will decide whether or not CPS begins a path to fiscal stability — or plunges right into a tailspin that may make restoration brutally painful.
Closing the hole was already a herculean activity when it stood at $529 million, earlier than the interim CEO added $175 million within the type of a pension reimbursement that Metropolis Corridor has been making an attempt to strong-arm CPS into over the past 12 months. Now, at $734 million, an answer is all however inconceivable with out cuts to essential applications. The Municipal Staff’ Annuity and Profit Fund of Chicago (MEABF) pension fund, created in 1921, covers each metropolis employees and CPS non-teaching workers. But two-thirds of this price belongs to the town, and the town controls the tax levy designated to cowl this pension fund. The legislation clearly states that it’s the metropolis’s sole duty to fund MEABF, not CPS. The district did make partial reimbursements underneath an intergovernmental settlement in the course of the COVID period, when it was flush with $3 billion in federal reduction. That reduction is now gone, however the mayor is insisting that CPS proceed to pay.
Let’s be clear: There is no such thing as a great way for CPS to pay this $175 million reimbursement. Income choices are almost nonexistent. Property taxes have already been raised to the authorized restrict, and CPS can elevate cash solely via a referendum, which there is no such thing as a time for. Even with out the pension cost, CPS is being pressured to make painful decisions. Including $175 million to the burden is like tossing a cinderblock to somebody on the verge of drowning. It pushes any crucial cuts from tough to catastrophic.
Metropolis Corridor’s advised resolution for paying the pension reimbursement? CPS ought to simply borrow the cash. However a short-term, high-interest mortgage is a deeply dangerous transfer that merely kicks an excellent heavier can down the highway. Borrowing to plug this 12 months’s gap could really feel like a simple repair, nevertheless it’s no repair in any respect. It will saddle CPS with elevated curiosity funds and deepen the district’s future finances deficits, simply because the district faces one more monetary cliff subsequent 12 months.
CPS continues to be paying almost $200 million per 12 months in curiosity on short-term borrowing from its final disaster, between 2016 and 2018. These funds will final till 2048.
Had the district averted borrowing then, this 12 months’s deficit could be smaller. Repeating previous errors now will solely assure deeper hurt to college students and colleges tomorrow.
Even within the brief time period, borrowing poses main dangers. Utilizing debt to cowl working prices would possible set off a credit score downgrade, dropping CPS even additional into junk bond territory. That downgrade would elevate borrowing prices throughout the board, deepening the deficit and limiting future choices.
The implications are actual. First, larger rates of interest would make CPS’ debt dearer, worsening future finances gaps. Second, most CPS borrowing helps capital wants, particularly constructing upkeep. If borrowing turns into extra pricey, even much less will likely be performed to repair the district’s $14 billion restore backlog. Third, CPS is banking on saving $100 million by refinancing current debt at higher charges. A downgrade dangers erasing these financial savings and creating a brand new $100 million hole this 12 months alone.
And whereas these numbers could really feel summary, the impacts are usually not. Rising borrowing prices divert {dollars} away from lecture rooms, counselors and scholar helps. The true price isn’t simply felt by taxpayers; it’s paid by youngsters, who lose entry to the schooling assets they deserve.
CPS is portray itself right into a nook by making an attempt to cowl the town’s MEABF pension invoice. All of it however ensures the district’s solely exit is thru borrowing. However any mortgage is a harmful gamble with the futures of a whole lot of hundreds of scholars.
Editorial: State management of Chicago Public Colleges grows likelier as finances disaster intensifies
A mortgage now may set off a spiral of rising deficits, curiosity funds and extra borrowing, culminating in CPS being locked out of credit score markets completely. That’s precisely what occurred in 1980, when the state needed to step in and take over. That form of disaster may undo the hard-won authority of Chicago’s newly elected faculty board earlier than it even begins.
Importantly, when engaged, the general public has been clear: Chicagoans overwhelmingly oppose CPS paying the town’s pension invoice, they usually oppose borrowing to cowl the present hole with or with out the pension expense.
The Board of Training ought to reject this shortsighted proposal. CPS exists to teach college students, to not subsidize metropolis pensions. Chicago’s youngsters, households and taxpayers deserve higher. They deserve a faculty finances that protects the classroom, preserves fiscal integrity, and places youngsters first.
Daniel Anello is CEO of Youngsters First Chicago. Joe Ferguson is president of the Civic Federation.
Submit a letter, of not more than 400 phrases, to the editor right here or e-mail letters@chicagotribune.com.