Mysterious crimes shatter serenity in Hamptons and Montauk over many years
NEWNow you can hearken to Fox Information articles!
Within the often serene New York seascape of the Hamptons and Montauk, a sequence of brutal crimes has often shattered tranquility.
From the wealth‑entangled homicide of financier Ted Ammon in 2001 to grim violence in Montauk parks in 2019, and now a mysterious dying aboard a ship on the famend Montauk Yacht Membership, the area has seen a scattering of violent crimes in latest many years.
Whereas Martha Nolan’s mysterious dying is the latest to rattle the area’s sun-soaked serenity, it’s removed from the one unsettling incident in latest many years to disrupt life within the Hamptons.
IRISH BEAUTY WHO SOLD BIKINIS FOUND DEAD ON BOAT AT LUXURY YACHT CLUB, HOMICIDE COPS PROBE
Martha Nolan, 33, owned a swimwear firm based mostly in Manhattan, New York. Her model featured high-end bikinis. (Fb/ Martha Nolan)
Bikini model founder – August 2025
On Tuesday, the picturesque peninsula’s visitors have been rocked by the invention of 33-year-old Martha Nolan-O’Slatarra. In accordance with Suffolk County police, East Hampton City officers responded to a 911 name simply after midnight from a person who reported a girl unconscious on a vessel docked on the luxurious marina, positioned on Star Island Highway.
Close by good Samaritans tried CPR earlier than first responders arrived, however the girl was pronounced useless on the scene, police stated.
On Wednesday, police recognized the deceased as Nolan, an industrious entrepreneur. They stated that her dying “didn’t present proof of violence.” Authorities stated the preliminary investigation and medical examination have been “inconclusive” as to the reason for dying.
An official ruling might be made following an post-mortem by the Suffolk County Medical Examiner’s Workplace.
EXCLUSIVE WATERFRONT ENCLAVE ROCKED AFTER BODY FOUND NEAR YACHT CLUB
Initially from Carlow, Eire, Nolan was the founding father of East x East, a boutique resort put on label she often promoted on TikTok by trendy behind-the-scenes glimpses of her photograph shoots and design course of.
Generic view of Montauk Lighthouse and seaside in Lengthy Island, New York. (iStock)
Love triangle homicide – June 2019
Within the early hours of June 6, 2019, Montauk’s sleepy calm was pierced by the dying of 38-year-old Robert Casado.
In accordance with the Suffolk County District Lawyer’s Workplace, Casado, a seasonal employee, had anticipated to satisfy somebody for a job. As a substitute, authorities stated, he was ambushed by Joseph Grippo, a 47-year-old Montauk native carrying a 36-inch pickaxe deal with on Kirk Park Path in Montauk.
Grippo bludgeoned Casado to dying, delivering a number of blows with the makeshift weapon and fleeing earlier than police arrived. A love triangle motive emerged because the main principle after prosecutors revealed that each Casado and Grippo have been concerned with the identical girl.
Joseph Grippo, 50, was charged in 2022 with manslaughter within the first diploma after he bludgeoned an ex-girlfriend’s love curiosity to dying. Grippo now faces 20 years in jail plus 5 years post-release supervision on the manslaughter cost. (Suffolk County Police Division)
In accordance with prosecutors, Grippo had harbored resentment for months. Prosecutors discovered that Grippo had deliberate the deadly assault for months, buying the makeshift homicide weapon months beforehand.
Following an intense native investigation and practically three years of authorized back-and-forth, Grippo pleaded responsible to first-degree manslaughter in July 2022. He was sentenced to twenty years in jail, with 5 extra years of post-release supervision.
Suffolk County District Lawyer Ray Tierney known as the act “a chilly, calculated plan to homicide a person he lured right into a secluded space beneath false pretenses.”
Counter-clockwise from left to proper, Amber Lynn Costello, 27, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, 25, Megan Waterman, 22, and Melissa Barthelemy, 24, disappeared after assembly with a consumer on Craigslist. The stays of the ladies have been present in December 2010 at Gilgo Seashore on Lengthy Island. (Suffolk County Police Division)
Our bodies within the dunes: The Gilgo Seashore murders – 2010
What started as a lacking particular person case within the spring of 2010 would spiral into some of the disturbing serial homicide investigations. When 24-year-old Shannan Gilbert vanished after fleeing a consumer’s residence in Oak Seashore, Suffolk County police initially suspected she had drowned within the close by marshland. Nevertheless, as investigators searched the comb alongside Ocean Parkway, they unearthed 4 our bodies wrapped in burlap.
The ladies have been later recognized as Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, Amber Costello and Maureen Brainard‑Barnes. That they had all marketed escort providers on-line. The press dubbed them the “Gilgo 4.”
WATCH ‘ARCHITECT OF DEATH: THE LONG ISLAND SERIAL KILLER’ ON FOX NATION
Over the next months, extra units of stays have been uncovered, together with Valerie Mack, Jessica Taylor, Tanya Jackson and her toddler daughter Tatiana, and an individual referred to for years solely as “Asian Doe.”
Rex Heuermann seems in Decide Tim Mazze’s courtroom along with his lawyer, Michael Brown, at Suffolk County Court docket in Riverhead, New York, on Wednesday, March 12, 2025. (James Carbone/Newsday through Pool)
The discoveries fueled hypothesis of a doable serial killer. The investigation stalled till, in July 2023, police arrested 59-year-old Rex Heuermann.
Heuermann, a 59-year-old architect from Massapequa Park, was charged with the murders of Barthelemy, Waterman and Costello, and later named the prime suspect in Brainard-Barnes’s killing. Investigators used cellphone data, burner telephone exercise, DNA forensics and surveillance footage to cost him.
By 2024, prosecutors added extra prices, and accused Heuermann of luring victims to his residence and killing them in his soundproofed basement. Heuermann has pleaded not responsible to all prices. He stays in custody whereas prosecutors push for a trial.
Aerial view of the house of financier Ted Ammon at 59 Center Lane in East Hampton, Lengthy Island, New York. Ammon was discovered murdered there in 2001; Daniel Pelosi is now being charged with the homicide. (Mark Bonifacio/NY Day by day Information Archive through Getty Photos)
SIGN UP TO GET THE TRUE CRIME NEWSLETTER
Wall Avenue financier homicide – Oct. 2001
In October 2021, the crisp autumn air of East Hampton was pierced by the blugeoning dying of Ted Ammon, a Wall Avenue financier. Ammon was discovered bare in his main bedroom at 59 Center Lane, his property in East Hampton.
His chauffeur, arriving after Ammon missed a enterprise assembly, found the scene: a excessive‑tech alarm system had been deactivated, there have been no indicators of pressured entry or theft, and his physique bore 30–35 wounds to the top.
FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X
On the heart of the homicide investigation was Ammon’s divorce from Generosa Ammon, with whom he had adopted twins from Ukraine in 1992. Generosa, amid contentious divorce proceedings, had employed Daniel Pelosi, an electrician and contractor, to work on her Manhattan townhome.
Daniel Pelosi in and round his residence, spending quiet time reflecting on his authorized issues. (John Roca/NY Day by day Information through Getty Photos)
Daniel Pelosi was convicted of second-degree homicide in 2004 and sentenced to 25 years to life in jail, the place he stays. (John Roca/NY Day by day Information through Getty Photos)
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
Their friendship blossomed into an affair. Following Ammon’s homicide, eyebrows have been raised by Generosa and Pelosi’s speedy marriage.
It took practically three years for the case to culminate in a conviction. In March 2004, Pelosi was arrested and later convicted of second-degree homicide, receiving a 25‑to‑life sentence.
Generosa, in August 2003, died of breast most cancers and the adopted twins inherited the majority of their father’s property, estimated within the tens of tens of millions, whereas Pelosi remained incarcerated.
Pelosi later claimed that he was the autumn man within the homicide investigation.
“I didn’t do it,” Pelosi advised Piers Morgan on FOX Nation’s “The Killer Interview.” “I didn’t do that homicide. I didn’t kill Ted Ammon.”